Call for Anarchy
Saturday, July 9, 2022
Monday, June 22, 2020
Thursday, May 16, 2019
Saturday, April 13, 2019
Wednesday, August 8, 2018
Monday, June 7, 2010
Libertarians, Marxists, and Christianity
Normally I refrain from re-posting. Not that there's anything wrong with that. These days of free web pages anyone and everyone can and often has their own way of story telling. This article at Lew Rockwell.com hit the ball so far out of the park, It wouldn't be right not to share it with anyone that I can. Without further ado Dr. William L. Anderson.
In an earlier article, I looked at two of Jim Wallis’ criticisms of libertarianism, and also compared his own historical “Christian Marxism” to the libertarian point of view. What I found was something akin to Jesus’ admonition that people with beams in their own eyes should focus first on their own condition rather than to be criticizing others.
This time, I examine the following two attacks that Wallis makes on libertarianthinking:
In an earlier article, I looked at two of Jim Wallis’ criticisms of libertarianism, and also compared his own historical “Christian Marxism” to the libertarian point of view. What I found was something akin to Jesus’ admonition that people with beams in their own eyes should focus first on their own condition rather than to be criticizing others.
This time, I examine the following two attacks that Wallis makes on libertarianthinking:
- “The Libertarians’ supreme confidence in the market is not consistent with a biblical view of human nature and sin”;
- “The Libertarian preference for the strong over the weak is decidedly un-Christian”;
The Libertarians’ supreme confidence in the market is not consistent with a biblical view of human nature and sin. The exclusive focus on government as the central problem ignores the problems of other social sectors, and in particular, the market. When government regulation is the enemy, the market is set free to pursue its own self-interest without regard for public safety, the common good, and the protection of the environment ― which Christians regard as God’s creation. Libertarians seem to believe in the myth of the sinless market and that the self-interest of business owners or corporations will serve the interests of society; and if they don’t, it’s not government’s role to correct it.Wallis then adds:
But such theorizing ignores the practical issues that the public sector has to solve. Should big oil companies like BP simply be allowed to spew oil into the ocean? And is regulating them really un-American? Do we really want nobody to inspect our meat, make sure our kids’ toys are safe, or police the polluters to keep our air clean? Do we really want owners of restaurants and hotels to be able to decide whom they will or won’t serve, or should liquor store owners also be able to sell alcohol to our kids?Now, I cannot say that I have read anything on any libertarian website or any publication or book espousing a libertarian point of view, and that includes Walter Block’s “plumb line libertarian” book, Defending the Undefendable, in which someone claims that markets are “sinless.” For example, a Christian who believes that adultery is a sin will not endorse prostitution, even if that same person believes that prostitution should not be a crime.
Thursday, May 6, 2010
The Beginning
Let's go back before there was order or as I like to phrase it controlled disorder within society.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)